When They Grow Up
As we grow in our lives we take steps toward certain goals. As babies we learn to crawl...(unless you are talking about my son, who scooted, then ran...there was no in between...I think that was the first indication of his ADHD...which he doesn't really have.) As toddlers we learn to interact with others, first by playing near them, then with them...there is a progression. As teenagers...well, I don't think anyone knows for sure what a teenager wants except a teenager, and they aren't talking. But one thing we learn at that age is WHO we really are...we try to find our own identities so we can be unique and individual...just like everyone else.
As young adults we learn a lot of lessons...and continue those steps toward a final goal. We are told we must get an education, get a job, and become part of the 'work force.' Most of the time...it is done in that order. (I skiped the education part and went right for the jobs...a lot of them...a lot of very bad jobs.) But I am now working on the education part.
What I began to wonder, as I thought about this concept of stepping toward an end goal is..."What is that end goal?" How do we define success in life? Some will say it is by achieving a certain amount of income in your job. Others will say that getting married and having a family equals success. And still others say that true success lies in the position of power that one has achieved in life.
These, of course, are what I gather from society as a whole...in the world in which I live. I live in the west...of course...in AMERICA!!!! And while I think America is the greatest country on the planet...I would be arrogant to think that our way of thinking was the only one that existed or was even valid on the planet. That could not be more clear in my current situation.
Now I am over here in Baghdad, helping to achieve an ultimate end goal. But are we the only ones here with a goal in mind, and is it the same as those whom we are trying to help? I wonder.
Of course, I believe our end goal is to eventually leave here with an Iraqi government that can stand on its own and sustain the country self sufficiently. Peace...whatever that really means...could be the end goal. Stability (another relative term) could be a minimum goal...at least.
So...the way I see it, is like this.
Once upon a time, there was this little...newly formed government that was trying to prove itself to the rest of the world. It was young, yes...but old enough to know the sorrow and pain of years of war. It had fought to prove that it could stand alone in a world of varied governments. After establishing itself and beginning to function as its own entity, it hit a sort of speed bump.
Civil War.
Why? Beliefs...values...things each individual...as well as different sections of society…held as true...and the differences in this things. Interpretations of laws and words that the government was built on tore the young government apart. Seeing things only one way, and not giving even a moment to the idea that there may be another way to think about things, was one of the biggest flaws of those that built and fought over this new little government.
The country was divided. Those who believed one way took up arms against those who thought another. And over what? RIGHTS...of all things. Freedoms!!!! So basically it was: "You are going to think the way I do, or I am going to force you to do so."
And then, they fought.
We Fought.
There was a time in our History as the United States of America that the streets were just as violent as those of Baghdad today. But in the end…we grew from it. It is a horrible and embarrassing time in our history, granted. But, despite all our differences...since that time we have come a long way. (Although we still have a LOT of work to do...Ironic...huh?) But we had our violent times and our own “RECONSTRUCTION.” In the end...we are the BIG BROTHER of the rest of the world...(and we did it all by ourselves.) We grew...and are working toward our own end goals as a country.
Now...the term “Reconciliation” is thrown around this place a lot. Let’s look at it a bit.
By Deffinition:
Reconciliation - rec‧on‧cil‧i‧a‧tion [rek-uh n-sil-ee-ey-shuh n]
n 1: the reestablishing of cordial relations [syn: rapprochement] 2: getting two things to correspond; "the reconciliation of his checkbook and the bank statement" [syn: balancing]
WordNet ® 2.0, © 2003 Princeton University
My question is this: Can we have true RECONCILIATION in Iraq?
Here is what I don’t understand. The people we are out here “Fighting”...fighting against and fighting for...have a completely different set of values than we have in the United States. Diplomacy is nothing to these people...(When I say ‘these people’ I mean the ones blowing themselves and everyone else up...not the ones actually attempting to establish and run a government...) Are we trying to do this thing with OUR values in place or are we trying to do it with THEIR values in mind?
The term extremist does nothing to describe the way these people think. If you say something (...words come out of your mouth, creating nothing more than vibrations that strike the ear drum and send signals to the brain which translates those signals into intelligible and coherent sounds, which strung together make words…words make sentences…and so on...) it can do no REAL harm. However, over here...these people have no qualms about killing you over something that you may SAY!
WHERE is the middle ground there? There is no such thing as talking and being diplomatic or trying to RECONCILE ANYTHING, if your first course of action is to attack someone...KILL them, even with no regard for who else may get killed or hurt in the process...over WORDS!!!!!! And it has been this way for a very long time...generations after generations.
So...what do we do? Do we (The big Green Machine that is the United States Army...and the rest of the Coalition) pull out and leave them to deal with this their way? When we do that...things will get worse. The people of Iraq have even said so. But they also say that it will not last long. Eventually the violence will decrease and slowly...it will stop. It has actually happened before...when this guy named Saddam was in charge...but, then that’s why we are here...right?
OR...do we stick around…dig in…and try to maintain a sense of balance in this country…All the while, trying to instill OUR values on a country that has and likely will handle things in a very different way than we do? Will this be our next Berlin?
Either way...ultimately...this country needs to grow on it’s own...without the presence of a Coalition of Nations around to fix its problems.
It is because of the differing values and belief systems that exist in this country that I believe this is taking longer than anyone had anticipated. The other thing is so cliché that it is almost too simple...and that is the fact that you can’t help someone who doesn’t want to be helped. Do I think the people here WANT to live life day to day at conflict because of which religious sect they belong to...or WANT to live in fear that they may be kidnapped, tortured, shot, or blown up at any given time?
No.
But I don’t necessarily think they want US here to help them fix their problems...not anymore. Not since we took Saddam out of power. That was the one thing they (in their minds) could not do alone...and THAT is what they needed us for. And we did it...now, why are we still here? Right?
I don’t want this to be interpreted as another soldier over in Iraq that doesn’t know what he is fighting for. That’s not the case. I know WHY we are here...and what WE are trying to accomplish. I just don’t know if it is what the people of Iraq really want from us.
Since history seems to always repeat itself...and I have spoken of the steps WE had to take in order to grow...I just wonder...What’s it going to be like when They Grow Up?
SFC NEWMAN
OUT
As young adults we learn a lot of lessons...and continue those steps toward a final goal. We are told we must get an education, get a job, and become part of the 'work force.' Most of the time...it is done in that order. (I skiped the education part and went right for the jobs...a lot of them...a lot of very bad jobs.) But I am now working on the education part.
What I began to wonder, as I thought about this concept of stepping toward an end goal is..."What is that end goal?" How do we define success in life? Some will say it is by achieving a certain amount of income in your job. Others will say that getting married and having a family equals success. And still others say that true success lies in the position of power that one has achieved in life.
These, of course, are what I gather from society as a whole...in the world in which I live. I live in the west...of course...in AMERICA!!!! And while I think America is the greatest country on the planet...I would be arrogant to think that our way of thinking was the only one that existed or was even valid on the planet. That could not be more clear in my current situation.
Now I am over here in Baghdad, helping to achieve an ultimate end goal. But are we the only ones here with a goal in mind, and is it the same as those whom we are trying to help? I wonder.
Of course, I believe our end goal is to eventually leave here with an Iraqi government that can stand on its own and sustain the country self sufficiently. Peace...whatever that really means...could be the end goal. Stability (another relative term) could be a minimum goal...at least.
So...the way I see it, is like this.
Once upon a time, there was this little...newly formed government that was trying to prove itself to the rest of the world. It was young, yes...but old enough to know the sorrow and pain of years of war. It had fought to prove that it could stand alone in a world of varied governments. After establishing itself and beginning to function as its own entity, it hit a sort of speed bump.
Civil War.
Why? Beliefs...values...things each individual...as well as different sections of society…held as true...and the differences in this things. Interpretations of laws and words that the government was built on tore the young government apart. Seeing things only one way, and not giving even a moment to the idea that there may be another way to think about things, was one of the biggest flaws of those that built and fought over this new little government.
The country was divided. Those who believed one way took up arms against those who thought another. And over what? RIGHTS...of all things. Freedoms!!!! So basically it was: "You are going to think the way I do, or I am going to force you to do so."
And then, they fought.
We Fought.
There was a time in our History as the United States of America that the streets were just as violent as those of Baghdad today. But in the end…we grew from it. It is a horrible and embarrassing time in our history, granted. But, despite all our differences...since that time we have come a long way. (Although we still have a LOT of work to do...Ironic...huh?) But we had our violent times and our own “RECONSTRUCTION.” In the end...we are the BIG BROTHER of the rest of the world...(and we did it all by ourselves.) We grew...and are working toward our own end goals as a country.
Now...the term “Reconciliation” is thrown around this place a lot. Let’s look at it a bit.
By Deffinition:
Reconciliation - rec‧on‧cil‧i‧a‧tion [rek-uh n-sil-ee-ey-shuh n]
n 1: the reestablishing of cordial relations [syn: rapprochement] 2: getting two things to correspond; "the reconciliation of his checkbook and the bank statement" [syn: balancing]
WordNet ® 2.0, © 2003 Princeton University
My question is this: Can we have true RECONCILIATION in Iraq?
Here is what I don’t understand. The people we are out here “Fighting”...fighting against and fighting for...have a completely different set of values than we have in the United States. Diplomacy is nothing to these people...(When I say ‘these people’ I mean the ones blowing themselves and everyone else up...not the ones actually attempting to establish and run a government...) Are we trying to do this thing with OUR values in place or are we trying to do it with THEIR values in mind?
The term extremist does nothing to describe the way these people think. If you say something (...words come out of your mouth, creating nothing more than vibrations that strike the ear drum and send signals to the brain which translates those signals into intelligible and coherent sounds, which strung together make words…words make sentences…and so on...) it can do no REAL harm. However, over here...these people have no qualms about killing you over something that you may SAY!
WHERE is the middle ground there? There is no such thing as talking and being diplomatic or trying to RECONCILE ANYTHING, if your first course of action is to attack someone...KILL them, even with no regard for who else may get killed or hurt in the process...over WORDS!!!!!! And it has been this way for a very long time...generations after generations.
So...what do we do? Do we (The big Green Machine that is the United States Army...and the rest of the Coalition) pull out and leave them to deal with this their way? When we do that...things will get worse. The people of Iraq have even said so. But they also say that it will not last long. Eventually the violence will decrease and slowly...it will stop. It has actually happened before...when this guy named Saddam was in charge...but, then that’s why we are here...right?
OR...do we stick around…dig in…and try to maintain a sense of balance in this country…All the while, trying to instill OUR values on a country that has and likely will handle things in a very different way than we do? Will this be our next Berlin?
Either way...ultimately...this country needs to grow on it’s own...without the presence of a Coalition of Nations around to fix its problems.
It is because of the differing values and belief systems that exist in this country that I believe this is taking longer than anyone had anticipated. The other thing is so cliché that it is almost too simple...and that is the fact that you can’t help someone who doesn’t want to be helped. Do I think the people here WANT to live life day to day at conflict because of which religious sect they belong to...or WANT to live in fear that they may be kidnapped, tortured, shot, or blown up at any given time?
No.
But I don’t necessarily think they want US here to help them fix their problems...not anymore. Not since we took Saddam out of power. That was the one thing they (in their minds) could not do alone...and THAT is what they needed us for. And we did it...now, why are we still here? Right?
I don’t want this to be interpreted as another soldier over in Iraq that doesn’t know what he is fighting for. That’s not the case. I know WHY we are here...and what WE are trying to accomplish. I just don’t know if it is what the people of Iraq really want from us.
Since history seems to always repeat itself...and I have spoken of the steps WE had to take in order to grow...I just wonder...What’s it going to be like when They Grow Up?
SFC NEWMAN
OUT